Gavin McCarthy has stood out as a rookie in Rochester. ©2026, Micheline Veluvolu, Rochester Americans

As rookie in Rochester, Sabres prospect Gavin McCarthy hitting, fighting and making name for himself

ROCHESTER – Having leveled Brett Berard inside the blue line, knocking the Laval Rocket winger to the ice and sending his stick flying, Buffalo Sabres prospect Gavin McCarthy knew he must answer the bell.

So late in Friday’s 3-1 loss, McCarthy, a rookie defenseman for the Americans, fought Braden Hache, who stepped in after the clean hit.

McCarthy, 21, hadn’t dropped his gloves since Dec. 2, 2022, according to hockeyfights.com, as a member of the junior Muskegon Lumberjacks.

“It’s good to get back into it, for sure, get the first one out of the way,” McCarthy told the Times Herald following Tuesday’s practice in Blue Cross Arena.

The entire sequence helps illustrate what makes the Clarence Center native such an intriguing youngster.

“He’s a competitive kid,” Amerks coach Mike Leone said. “Like, he’s willing to get in there. He plays with assertiveness. He’s willing to engage in contact, and I think it’s really good for a young D to see that.”

Leone said the competitiveness McCarthy possesses can’t be taught.

“When someone is competitive like that and it’s natural, I think that goes a long way for a young player,” he said. “… When someone’s ultra-competitive, that’s something that comes from inside, and I think Gav has that in him.”

Leone often says young defensemen can’t hide in the AHL. Their mistakes will be exploited.

But in his first weeks as a regular in the AHL – he played five games late last season after leaving Boston University following his junior year – McCarthy has looked comfortable, showcasing his versatile game.

“His game is in a good place right now,” Leone said. “He’s gapping. He’s moving the puck quicker. I think that was the one thing, he was hanging onto too many pucks and not exiting the zone quick. But he’s doing a great job for us right now.”

McCarthy, who has a heavy shot, has also created offense. The six points he has recorded in 12 games – he scored his only goal Oct. 23 – ranks second among Amerks defensemen behind Caleb Jones’ nine points.

“He’s a guy that skates very well, so as much as we can get him into the offensive zone where he can use his creativity, I think that’s where he is best,” said Amerks assistant coach Philip Samuelsson, who’s in charge of the defense.

The Amerks, who have started 8-6-1 this season entering Wednesday’s road contest against the Syracuse Crunch, are light on prospects. They’re a veteran-laden team.

McCarthy, a third-round pick in 2023, 86th overall, is one of just five players on the AHL roster the Sabres drafted and awarded an NHL contract.

Some of the Sabres’ other defense prospects often overshadow McCarthy.

They selected Amerks rookie Radim Mrtka ninth in 2025 and Daxon Rudolph, who’s starring for the University of Denver, fourth in June. Meanwhile, Adam Kleber and Luke Osburn have developed into high-end NCAA players.

Still, the 6-foot-2, 194-pound McCarthy deserves to be mentioned among those names.

In training camp, Sabres coach Lindy Ruff said, “He’s a guy that should be able to play at some point,” meaning he’s expected to crack the NHL someday.

“Coming from him, he’s a legend,” McCarthy said. “So if he sees that, it means a lot to me. It’s just something I try to keep working for.”

–

The Sabres on Tuesday assigned rookie defenseman Max Strbak from Rochester to the ECHL Orlando Solar Bears.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *